The Inner Touch: Archaeology of a Sensation

By Daniel Heller-Roazen

Book Overview

An original, elegant, and far-reaching philosophical inquiry into what it means to feel alive.

The Inner Touch presents the archaeology of a single sense: the sense of being sentient. Aristotle was perhaps the first to define this faculty when in his treatise On the Soul he identified a sensory power, irreducible to the five senses, by which animals perceive that they are perceiving: the simple "sense," as he wrote, "that we are seeing and hearing." After him, thinkers returned, time and again, to define and redefine this curious sensation. The classical Greek and Roman philosophers as well as the medieval Arabic, Hebrew, and Latin thinkers who followed them all investigated a power they called "the common sense," which one ancient author likened to "a kind of inner touch, by which we are able to grasp ourselves." Their many findings were not lost with the waning of the Middle Ages. From Montaigne and Francis Bacon to Locke, Leibniz, and Rousseau, from nineteenth-century psychiatry and neurology to Proust and Walter Benjamin, the writers and thinkers of the modern period have turned knowingly and unknowing to the terms of older traditions in exploring the perception that every sensitive being possesses of its life. The Inner Touch reconstructs and reconsiders the history of this perception. In twenty-five concise chapters that move freely among ancient, medieval, and modern cultures, Daniel Heller-Roazen investigates a set of exemplary phenomena that have played central roles in philosophical, literary, psychological, and medical accounts of the nature of animal existence. Here sensation and self-sensation, sleeping and waking, aesthetics and anesthetics, perception and apperception, animal nature and human nature, consciousness and unconsciousness, all acquire a new meaning. The Inner Touch proposes an original, elegant, and far-reaching philosophical inquiry into a problem that has never been more pressing: what it means to feel that one is alive.Winner of the Aldo and Jeanne Scaglione Prize for Comparative Literary Studies

• Format: Paperback
• Language: English
• ISBN: 1890951773
• ISBN13: 9781890951771
• Release Date: September 2009
• Publisher: Zone Books
• Length: 392 Pages
• Weight: 1.38 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.2" x 6.0" x 8.9"
• Age Range: 18 years and up
• Grade Range: Postsecondary and higher

Customer Reviews

"L'interne attouchement" (Montaigne)

About halfway in the text, introducing the works of medieval commentators of classic authors, Daniel Heller-Roazen gives a definition of his own work. "Glossators and their kind are incessantly in search of the animating element in their textual objects that bears no name: the dimension in them that, remaining unsaid, demands in time to be exposed." Much remained unsaid about the "common sense" by which, according to Aristotle, the white and the sweet of milk can be the object of a single sensation. Discussion of the matter fills less than a single page in his work. The philosopher makes it clear that this shared faculty of sensation cannot be counted as a sixth sense: "there is no sense other than the five, and by which I mean sight, hearing, smell, taste, and touch". The idea of an "inner sense" by which we perceive ourselves is therefore not Aristotle's own. It was proposed by medieval scholars who combined the Aristotelian doctrine of sensation with the teachings of the Stoics, who held that the sensation of external things could not be accomplished without a "self-sensation" that one is perceiving. This "inner touch" of the Aristotelian tradition is not just an intellectual curiosa. It suggests that consciousness, of which the Greek authors and their Latin language heirs had no clear concept, may be closer to sensation than to cognition. The faculty by which we perceive ourselves as being may not be the Cogito of Descartes but rather an inner sense intimately linked to tact and contact. Sentio ergo sum: "I sense, therefore I am". According to this line of thought, animals, as sentient beings, have a perception of themselves, and we also maintain a sensation of sensing in the liminal states of consciousness such as sleep and awakening. And our contemporary world, where feelings of emptiness prevail and our senses are becoming duller by the day, may be characterized by a loss of existence. Daniel Heller-Roazen's books are often linked to political and ethical questions. In The Enemy of All, he addresses the issue of piracy from the perspective of political philosophy and international law, with obvious ramifications to our present day's airplane hijackers and illegal enemy combatants. In Echolalias, the linguistic exploration of the forgetting of language leads to considerations about the fate of cultural diversity and the effects of globalization. This essay's political dimension is less obvious, and it is more innerly directed. The pattern of presentation, however, is the same as in his previous books. After a literary prologue, the origin of a philosophical topos is found in Antiquity, most likely in Aristotle, the Greek scholar that generations of commentators referred to as, simply, the Philosopher. The Aristotelian tradition is then tracked, not only through the works of medieval commentators from the Judeo-Christian tradition, but also in the writings of scholars in the Arabo-Persian civilization (As far as the history of civil