New Worlds, Ancient Texts: The Power of Tradition and the Shock of Discovery

By Anthony Grafton and April Shelford

Book Overview

On encountering what he called the Indies, the Jesuit Jose de Acosta wrote, Having read what poets and philosophers write of the Torrid Zone, I persuaded myself that when I came to the Equator, I would not be able to endure the violent heat, but it turned out to be otherwise... What could I do then but laugh at Aristotle's Meteorology and his philosophy? Acosta's experience echoes that of his fellow travellers to the New World, and it is this experience, with its profound effect on Western culture, that Anthony Grafton charts. Describing an era of exploration that went far beyond geographic bounds, this book shows how the evidence of the New World shook the foundations of the old, upsetting the authority of the ancient texts that had guided Europeans so far afield.

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0674618750
• ISBN13: 9780674618756
• Release Date: January 1992
• Publisher: Belknap Press
• Length: 282 Pages
• Weight: 2.19 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.3" x 8.3" x 9.6"

Customer Reviews

Re-imagining the (Renaissance) World

'New Worlds, Ancient Texts' was the companion to a 1992 exhibition of the same name at the New York Public Library. What is amazing is how well this book still stands on its own years later and in absentia from that exhibition. Grafton (with help from Nancy Siraisi) shows how the ancient authors--on which 16th/17th c. Europeans relied so heavily to explain the known (and unknown) world--utterly failed to provide an adequate roadmap to the cosmos in the face of the discovery and exploration of the Americas. "Between 1550 and 1650," writes Grafton, "Western thinkers ceased to believe that they could find all important truths in ancient books." As a result, Europeans were forced to confront the paucity of much of the classical knowledge on which they had relied for so long, and begin to develop their own mechanisms, theories, and models for understanding the world. This suggests the beginning of 'modern' knowledge; early-modern Europeans finally began to think for themselves, even if they still operated under the "shades of old images." Grafton offers some fascinating examples of just how far the Europeans were willing to stretch the authority of the ancients to try accommodate new knowledge. In almost every case, the ancients were stretched so far they snapped. In Grafton's capable hands, this short (and nicely illustrated) work is one of the best books available for understanding the impact of the discovery of the new world on the West's classical intellectual heritage.

overseas overviews

Not the most stunning or innovative of Professor Grafton's works, makes a sweeping review from the expectations held by the world of humanists received from Greek, Latin, and Arabic forerunners to the explosion and expansion of these expectations due to America's discovery. Grafton is a smooth and engaging writer, who can bind the vast realms of his study into fine sentences and clear argumentation.The text consists of five chapters, intermittent miniature biographies of more interesting or less frequently known players, and luxurious black and white reproductions of images and manuscripts of the age. The text runs its course and neither references the small biographies nor acknowledges the handsome illustrations. It is very possible that one will skip over these images as accessory to follow the sweep of the author's narrative, only to revisit them later. Sweeps and anecdotes describe the nature of the investigation rather than patient analysis of sites and sights. This book seems to share only the prettiest berries plucked from Grafton's years as a tender of the tree.This book more than adequately accounts for the changes in European thought on account of the discovery not just of new lands, but of new worlds, new diseases, drugs, and, as important, the discovery of the limitations of many ancient texts. Again, Grafton is beguiling, informative and masterful at his craft. will be equally welcome reading for those who enjoy the period and those who wish to find a compelling way to enter it.

A correction to my earlier review

I posted a review here on October 10. I want to make a small correction, in case I confused anyone. The book I recommended looking at, if you can find a copy, is "Off the Beaten TRACK in the Classics," not "Off the Beaten PATH...." The author is C. Kaeppel, and it was published in Melbourne, Australia, in 1936.