If you are looking for light fantasy, a quick escape from the world, this book is not for you. If you love poetry and language, puzzles and riddles, myth and folklore, Moonwise will delight you, if you are willing to take on a challenge. Be warned, Greer Gilman paints -- beautifully -- with old English and dialect, words so fallen out of use that you will only find them in the OED, not Webster's. She weaves meaning with...
0Report
No doubt one man's cloud is another man's clod, but that Publisher's Weekly view seems particularly misleading and tonedeaf to "Moonwise." (...) Look at some other evaluations of the book: "Moonwise remarkably attempts to compose an entire long fantasy at a pitch and density of language reminiscent of Gerard Manley Hopkins . . . . GIG's deep knowledge of English etymology (including dialectal variations) charges every word...
0Report
Greer Ilene Gilman is one of the most significant writers in the world today and I hope she gives us something new to follow up to or surpass her wonderful classic "Moonwise". We do not go to "Moonwise" for plot. We go to it for an experience of language that makes us feel as if the roots of psychic and telluric realities have been laid bare. The book can only be compared to James Joyce's astonishing "Finnegans Wake" but unlike...
0Report
I read over the other reviews and have a secret to share with you about this book. It's a book that should be read out loud. The poetry, the rhythms of this book are wonderful. And what emerges is something quite different from when you read it silently to yourself.
0Report
Moonwise grabbed me the first time I read it 7 years ago. I read it probably half a dozen times in the first year and have not missed a year since. One reason I kept re-reading it was to try to understand it, and I understand more each time. It feels at once utterly foreign and deeply, personally familiar. The visual imagery is vivid and dreamlike. If I don't read it at least once each year (starting just before Winter...
0Report